CompletionStage.thenCompose 没有串行执行

Question

我正在尝试使用 java 8 个 CompletionStages 来串行执行 2 个异步方法，以便在第一个失败时不执行第二个。但是当我调用 thenCompose 时，传入的函数似乎在前一个函数完成之前就开始了（例如：这两个函数错误地并行执行。代码如下：

  public CompletionStage<Graph> create(Payload payload) {
    CompletionStage<BlobInfo> fileFuture = createFile(payload);
    CompletionStage<Entity> metadataFuture = createMetadata(payload);
    return fileFuture
        .thenCompose(ignore -> metadataFuture)
        .thenApply(entity ->
            buildFromEntity(objectMapper, entity));
  }

  public CompletionStage<BlobInfo> createFile(Payload payload) {
    return CompletableFuture.supplyAsync(() -> {
      try {
        return
            storage.create(
                BlobInfo
                    .newBuilder(payload.bucket, payload.name)
                    .build(),
                payload.data.getBytes());
      } catch (StorageException e) {
        LOG.error("Failed to write to storage: " + e);
        throw new RequestHandlerException(StatusCode.SERVER_ERROR,
            "Failed to write to storage.");
      }
    });
  }


  public CompletionStage<Entity> createMetadata(Payload payload) {
    return CompletableFuture.supplyAsync(() -> createSync(payload));
  }

  private Entity createMetadataSync(Payload payload) {
    Key key = keyFactory.newKey(payload.id);
    Entity.Builder entityBuilder = GraphPayload.buildEntityFromGraph(payload, key);
    Entity entity = entityBuilder.build();
    LOG.error("Metadata.createSync");

    try {
      datastore.add(entity);
    } catch (DatastoreException e) {
      LOG.error("Failed to write initial metadata: " + e);
      throw new RequestHandlerException(StatusCode.SERVER_ERROR,
          "Failed to write initial metadata.");
    }
    return entity;
  }

输出：

16:57:47.530 [ForkJoinPool.commonPool-worker-3] ERROR com.spotify.nfgraphstore.store.FileStore - CreateFile
16:57:47.530 [ForkJoinPool.commonPool-worker-2] ERROR com.spotify.nfgraphstore.store.MetadataStore - Metadata.createSync
16:57:47.530 [ForkJoinPool.commonPool-worker-3] ERROR com.spotify.nfgraphstore.store.FileStore - Failed to write initial graph to storage: com.google.cloud.storage.StorageException: X

记录的输出表明 Metadata.createSync 在存储异常被抛出之前被执行。如果对文件存储 DB 的写入失败，该结论也由一项测试（未显示）得出，该测试应该显示与元数据 DB 的零交互。该测试有时会失败，表明存在竞争条件。

所以我认为 thenCompose 不能保证串行执行。但是我在 java 文档中阅读的所有内容都表明执行应该是串行的：https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/util/concurrent/CompletionStage.html#thenCompose-java.util.function.Function-

有谁知道为什么不能保证串行执行，或者推荐其他可能更符合我预期的功能？

Answer 1

调用 createMetadata 会立即启动任务，因为它不是作为传递给 thenCompose.

的 lambda 表达式的一部分调用的

也许你打算这样做：

.thenCompose(ignore -> createMetadata(payload))

CompletionStage.thenCompose 没有串行执行

CompletionStage.thenCompose not executing serially

java

java-8

completable-future