标准委员会如何表明正在审议的论文的状态?

How does the standards committee indicate the status of a paper under consideration?

C++ 标准委员会是否(在 the open standard site 或其他地方)提供任何关于正在考虑中并在开放标准站点上编入索引的论文状态的指示?我指的是个人 "papers" 指出标准的潜在变化,并进行相关讨论,如下例所示;我不是指的是(已发布或草案)标准作为一个整体

比如,如何判断N3922是被接受还是被拒绝?

对于这种特殊情况,我们可以猜测这是来自论文背景部分的演化工作组 (EWG) 问题,其中说:

In Issaquah, EWG considered two alternative resolutions; this paper offers wording for one of the two, and mentions the other only as an acceptable alternative in case CWG uncovers fatal problems with EWG's preferred resolution.

从最新的C++ Standard Evolution Completed Issues List that the status of N3922 is WP. For the Evolution Working Group the issue statues are defined on the active issues list可以看出WP代表:

WP - (Working Paper) - The proposed resolution has not been accepted as a Technical Corrigendum, but the full WG21/PL22.16 committee has voted to apply the issue's resolution to the working paper.

事实上 issue 161 正在跟踪这篇论文说:

Adopted into the working draft in Urbana, as N3922.

我们可以找到最新的 EWG 和核心问题列表,从最近的 mailings and the latest mailings can be found off of the main WG21 site and going to the papers section 到最近的日期。

在一般情况下,post meeting mailing Disposition 列会告诉您论文的状态,例如来自 2015 the post-Lenexa mailing shows the Disposition column for proposal N4508 A proposal to add shared_mutex (untimed) (Revision 4) says Adopted 2015-05 and we can confirm by looking at the latest draft standard which is also part of the mailing: N4527 Working Draft, Standard for Programming Language C++ and it indeed contain the new and modified wording. We can also usually find the latest draft standard by going to this answer from the question "Where do I find the current C or C++ standard documents?"

这可能并不总是有帮助,在这种情况下 N3922 仅在 post-Issaquah mailing and has an empty Disposition but was later adopted Urbana but there is no indication of this in the post-Urbana mailing 中列出。

"post-Issaquah"和"post-Urbana"是什么意思?

C++ 标准会议通常以召开地点的名称来指代。我们可以在 isocpp.org site in the Upcoming Meetings, Past Meetings 部分找到完整列表。例如,2015 年 5 月的会议在堪萨斯州 Lenexa.

举行

每次会议前后都有一封邮件,其中列出了与该会议相关的所有文件,这些文件被称为 prepost 会议邮件,所以对于 Lenexa,我们有 pre-Lenexa mailing and post-Lenexa mailing。 post 会议邮件将包含会议纪要、更新的提案和可能的提案 处置 、标准的最新工作草案、更新的问题列表等...